• हिन्दीEnglishमराठीবাংলাதமிழ்മലയാളംગુજરાતીతెలుగుಕನ್ನಡଓଡ଼ିଶାZ BharatPHHBusinessWION
  • facebookyoutubetwitterwhatsapp
Zee News English
  • news
  • Live Blog
  • photos
Add Zee Business As A Preferred Source
App
  • Live TV
  • Latest News
  • India
  • World
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
  • Astrology
  • Auto
  • Education
  • Technology
  • News
  • /Business
  • /IDBI Bank slashes two prime property valuations before Fairfax sale; sparks valuation questions

IDBI Bank slashes two prime property valuations before Fairfax sale; sparks valuation questions

Valuation questions are arising as IDBI bank has abruptly marked down two prime properties ahead of Fairfax stake sale.

Written ByZee Media Bureau
Published: Nov 16, 2026, 10:45 IST|Updated: Nov 16, 2026, 10:51 IST
joinshare
IDBI Bank slashes two prime property valuations before Fairfax sale; sparks valuation questions

About the Author

    Zee Media Bureau

    Zee Media Bureau

    Zee Media Bureau is the editorial news desk of Zee Media Corporation, one of India’s leading news networks.The bureau represents a collective of experienced journalists, editors, and correspondents who work across television, digital, and social platforms to deliver timely, accurate, and wide-ranging news coverage. Zee Media Bureau's coverage spans politics, business, economy, technology, health, entertainment, and global affairs. The bureau follows a collaborative newsroom model, where stories are researched, verified, and published by a team. This ensures speed, editorial consistency, and adherence to journalistic standards, particularly for breaking news and developing stories.
    Read More

    Trending

    • News
    • Photos
    Cyclone 'Akwan' may intensify into severe storm; Chennai braces for very heavy rain on November 18-19

    Cyclone 'Akwan' may intensify into severe storm; Chennai braces for very heavy rain on November 18-19

    2

    Diljit Dosanjh invokes Rahat Indori’s ghazal over song restrictions at Indore concert: 'Ye nahi gaana, wo nahi gaana...'

    3

    IDBI Bank slashes two prime property valuations before Fairfax sale; sparks valuation questions

    4

    Ravie Dubey gets emotional over fans’ response to Ramayana, expresses heartfelt gratitude

    5

    Sai Pallavi discloses her mom got upset with her decision to cut her hair for her character in 'Om'

    logo
    • contact us
    • privacy policy
    • legal
    • investor info
    • advertise with us
    © 1998-2026 Indiadotcom Digital Private Limited, All Rights Reserved.

    IDBI Bank that owns vast real estate across India, has abruptly marked down the valuations of two of its prime properties ahead of the government's stake sale of the bank. IDBI Bank's realty ownership includes Mumbai headquarters, a 50-acre Hyderabad campus, and offices and flats nationwide. A report in the Businessworld notes that IDBI Bank cut Rs 2,122 crore from the value of two properties.

    The bank had only disclosed it in a single sentence deep inside its annual report. IDBI bank neither named the properties nor explained what went wrong, said the BW report, adding that the government's valuer then used these accounts to calculate IDBI Bank's worth.

    In October, the Cabinet approved selling the bank to Canada's Fairfax at Rs 81 per share. Businessworld points out, this raises a larger question about how all the other properties were valued. While the government says its valuer checked the bank's properties and title papers, it has not published a single figure. Until it does, no one outside the sale can verify if IDBI's hundreds of properties were priced fairly, notes BW.

    The Businessworld has carried out several reports on Fairfax-IDBI deal. In the latest edition to its ongoing series, BW has asked "The Fifth Question". Businessworld writes, "This is the fifth time" it has found "something in this sale that needs explaining." BS mentions the following elements:

    The price.

    An internal government note showed that officials opened Fairfax's bid, threw out their own minimum price, and only then ordered fresh valuations. Those came in below the bid.

    The boardroom.

    A director of LIC, which was selling its IDBI shares, sat on the board of a Fairfax-controlled company for seven months of the sale.

    The Companies.

    A day after winning, Fairfax said it would move its own insurance and broking businesses into IDBI, at market prices.

    The Money.

    Fairfax's chairman then told investors that IDBI would pay cash for those businesses. Fairfax counted that cash towards paying for IDBI. The government says it followed due process, and that two independent valuations supported the price.

    BW explains the "fifth question" which is about property and says, it comes from the bank's own books.

    Explaining Rs 2,122 crore

    BS explains the sentence, from the notes to IDBI's accounts for 2025-26:

    "Pursuant to certain legal developments affected two immovable properties of the Bank, which restrict the Bank's ability to sell the said properties, though they continue to remain in the Bank's un-interrupted possession/ownership, the Bank has revalued the said properties through independent valuers."

    "In plain words: something happened in law that stops the bank from freely selling two of its properties. The bank still owns them. It still uses them. But because it cannot sell them freely, it has decided they are worth Rs 2,122 crore less. That is all shareholders have been told. The bank has given no names, no addresses, and no account of the legal trouble. It has not said who valued the properties, or what they were worth before," writes BW.

    It adds, "No cash left the bank. The Rs 2,122 crore was struck off the paper value of the two properties."

    BS says, what makes the entire thing odd is what happened just before.

    "In March 2025, an independent valuer went through IDBI's properties and checked them against market prices. The verdict: they were worth Rs 2,855 crore more than the bank's books showed. The bank marked them up. A year later, the direction had reversed. IDBI's land and buildings stood at Rs 11,383 crore in March 2025. By March 2026, they were down to Rs 8,881 crore. The cut on the two properties is the biggest part of that fall that the bank has explained," writes BW.

    It further notes that IDBI bank does not say whether the two properties were among those marked up the year before.

    "Its half-yearly accounts suggest when the drop came: between October 2025 and March 2026. In those months, the government called for final bids for IDBI (8 January), received them (6 February) and opened them (12 March)," said BW.

    The newspaper questions whether Rs 81 was a fair price? The question was further pegged to further inferences, which BW explains as, "To answer that, the government relied on two valuations. One of them added up everything IDBI owns, land and buildings included. It was done by a firm called BDO Valuation Advisory."

    It wrote, an internal note of DIPAM, the government department that ran the sale, says which accounts BDO used. The note is dated 13 August 2026, and Businessworld has reported on it before:

    "The Asset Valuer has also submitted an updated valuation report as per the 31st March, 2026 closing accounts made available by the IDBI Bank."

    The BW narrows it down further saying, "Those are the accounts with the Rs 2,122 crore cut in them. The same note shows that the panel of secretaries running the sale gave the valuer an instruction -- The Asset Valuer must give point estimates which reflect professional opinion rather than scenarios which fail to correct the valuation of fixed assets as given by the Bank."

    The note does not say whether "correct" meant up or down. It gives no figure for what IDBI's property was finally valued at. The BDO report has never been made public, wrote BW.

    The report mentions about the two properties that government spoke of, though, it says, the bank has not named its two properties.

    "But one day after the Cabinet's decision, the man who ran the sale gave an interview. DIPAM Secretary Arunish Chawla told Business Standard that IDBI has "two most important properties." One is the "allotted property in Hyderabad, which is a training centre." Of that land, he said: "It cannot be transferred to anyone in any form and is not marketable," wrote BW

    It says, the other is "the leased property in Mumbai, which is the headquarters": "The Mumbai property is leased, so it has a fair market value for the lease." The valuer, he said, "researched the title papers and the land covenants and did a fair valuation at market rates." Asked what the properties were valued at, he replied: "I can tell you the methodology; the finer details are in the valuation reports," BW wrote

    BW mentions further, the bank's accounts speak of two properties it cannot freely sell. The government speaks of two main properties: one that cannot be sold at all, and one that is only leased.

    "Are they the same two? Businessworld could not confirm it. Neither the bank nor the government has said anywhere," wrote the BW.

    It further analysed the past story of the Hyderabad Land, spanning 39 years.

    BW hints that if the Hyderabad campus is one of the two, its history matters. The campus is 50 acres in Gachibowli, in the city's technology corridor. Court records tell how IDBI got it, and how it fought to keep it.

    The BW sketched each remarkable year as follows:

    1987: The state government gave IDBI the land for a staff training institute. IDBI paid Rs 25,000 an acre, the market price of the day.

    The catch: The grant let the government take the land back for a public purpose, paying no more than IDBI had paid.

    2007: The state took back 10 acres for another department.

    2008: IDBI went to the High Court and won. Justice N.V. Ramana set the takeover aside.

    2022: The state appealed and lost. A bench led by the Chief Justice said the state "has not done any charity to the Bank," which had paid market value. It said the state had shown no law that "entitles the State Government to resume the land, which has been allotted on payment of market value." It told officials to speed up permissions so the bank could build more on the campus.

    Explaining further inferences on the 'year of the Sale', BW wrote, "On 28 August 2026, the Telangana government auctioned a 5.38-acre plot at Raidurg, beside Gachibowli. It went for Rs 269 crore an acre, a record. IDBI’s campus is 50 acres. Former Union secretary E.A.S. Sarma and the bank officers’ union AIBOA have done the multiplication: at that rate, about Rs 13,450 crore. That is not what IDBI’s land is worth today. The Raidurg plot was sold outright at an open auction. IDBI’s land was given for a training institute, and the government says it cannot be sold."

    However, it said, the sum shows something is 'at stake'.

    "It is the gap between what the land is worth with its restrictions and what the land beside it fetches without them. All of IDBI’s land and buildings, across India, stand at Rs 8,881 crore in its books," BW wrote.

    "The conditions on the land were set in 1987. They have not changed in 39 years. In 2022, the High Court made the bank's hold on the land stronger, not weaker. In March 2025, a valuer marked the bank's properties up. Then came the year of the sale. The bank reported "legal developments" that stopped it from freely selling two properties. And Rs 2,122 crore came off their value. If the Hyderabad campus is one of the two, what was the legal development?" questioned BW, stating that the annual report does not say.

    "Cannot be transferred to anyone"

    Further explaining the 'puzzle in Mr Chawla's words', BW wrote, "He says the Hyderabad land "cannot be transferred to anyone in any form." The two court rulings quote one condition of the grant: the state's right to take the land back. Neither mentions a bar on transfer. The government has not published the document he is relying on. And in any case, the land is not being transferred. The bank that owns it is being sold. A campus that the state gave to a government-owned bank, for training bankers, will now be controlled by a private foreign investor - Fairfax."

    Has anyone asked the Telangana government? BW says, the sums here are not the whole sale.

    "Rs 2,122 crore is about Rs 2 a share. It does not explain why the government's benchmark fell from Rs 94.42 to Rs 75.99. At Rs 81 a share, Fairfax is valuing the whole bank at about Rs 87,100 crore, which is more than the bank's own capital and reserves of about Rs 71,550 crore. A bank is allowed to mark a property down when the law limits what it can do with it. And the government says its valuer did not simply copy the bank's books, but read the title papers of each property. Mr Chawla said the gap between book value and the final valuation "tells you the valuers have done a fair job," wrote BW.

    BW in its report has left several questions for the government to answer:

    Which two properties lost Rs 2,122 crore?
    What were the "legal developments", and when did they happen?
    What was each property worth before the cut, and who valued it?
    Did the government's valuer use the lower values, or work out its own?
    If the Hyderabad campus "cannot be transferred to anyone in any form", how does it pass to a privately controlled bank?
    Will the government publish the valuation report?
    Will the government publish what each of IDBI’s properties was valued at?

    "One sentence in an annual report took Rs 2,122 crore off two properties. Until the bank names them, and the government shows how it valued them, nobody outside this sale can say what they were really worth. And if the legal trouble ever clears, the gain will belong to a bank that Fairfax controls," wrote the Businessworld.
     

    Stay informed on all the latest news, real-time breaking news updates, and follow all the important headlines in india news and world news on Zee News English.

    Add Zee News as a Preferred Source
    TAGS:
    IDBI BANK