Held for over 24 hours before arrest: Delhi court grants bail to man in Rs 1 crore drone smuggling case
It added that holding someone for long hours while delaying the arrest is not allowed. Such detention, it said, violates Article 21 (right to life and personal liberty) and the safeguards under Article 22.
It added that holding someone for long hours while delaying the arrest is not allowed. Such detention, it said, violates Article 21 (right to life and personal liberty) and the safeguards under Article 22.
A Delhi court has granted bail to a man accused of smuggling drone parts worth over Rs 1 crore, holding that Customs officials kept him under restraint for too long before recording his arrest, in violation of his right to personal liberty.
Additional Sessions Judge Saurabh Partap Singh Laler passed the order on November 18 in favour of Shoaib Nawab Khan, who had been in judicial custody since September 27.
The court noted that Customs held Khan for more than 24 hours before formally arresting him. In the court's view, constitutional protection against unlawful detention starts the moment a person's liberty is curtailed, not when the paperwork shows an arrest.
The judge relied on Article 22(2), which says an arrested person must be produced before the nearest magistrate within 24 hours. Authorities, the court said, cannot get around this by putting off the formal arrest.
The court accepted that a passenger can be stopped for a short time after landing for baggage checks and routine formalities. It added that holding someone for long hours while delaying the arrest is not allowed. Such detention, it said, violates Article 21 (right to life and personal liberty) and the safeguards under Article 22.
Customs argument rejected
Customs had argued that Khan himself asked to rest at its office and to join the proceedings the next morning. It produced a written request signed by him.
The court did not accept this. It said such a request cannot be treated as Khan giving up his fundamental rights, and cannot justify keeping him under restraint for so long.
If officers did not have enough grounds to arrest him after the first round of questioning, the court said, they should have let him go and arrested him later if the investigation required it.
The case
According to Customs, Khan and two other passengers flew from Hong Kong to Delhi via Vietnam and landed at Terminal 3 of Indira Gandhi International Airport at about 11 pm on September 25.
The department says it seized 10 Autel Robotics drones along with remote controllers, adaptors, cables and other parts, together worth more than Rs 1 crore. Four remote controllers, 10 adaptors, 10 power cables and an iPhone were allegedly found in Khan's checked-in baggage, while another passenger was allegedly carrying the drone bodies.
The prosecution claims the drones were military-grade unmanned aerial vehicles whose import is banned.
Khan was picked up on the night of September 25 but his arrest was recorded only on September 27. A magistrate's court rejected his first bail plea on October 27.
The sessions court granted bail on a personal bond of Rs 1 lakh with one surety of the same amount. It made clear that its observations are only prima facie and limited to the bail application.
Stay informed on all the latest news, real-time breaking news updates, and follow all the important headlines in india news and world news on Zee News English.