SOCIAL MEDIA

Newsletter

PARTNER SITES
Select language

Why did India invite Pakistan Minister Malik despite his anti-India remarks? Explained

Prime Minister Narendra Modi inaugurated the first SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum in New Delhi on November 20. A photograph from the inaugural event became the centre of a political debate after the Congress shared it on social media.

Written By Zee Media Bureau
Published: Nov 20, 2026, 23:19 IST | Updated: Nov 20, 2026, 23:22 IST
Join

Prime Minister Narendra Modi inaugurated the first SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum in New Delhi on November 20. A photograph from the inaugural event became the centre of a political debate after the Congress shared it on social media.

The arrival of Pakistan's Climate Change Minister Musadik Masood Malik in New Delhi for the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) Civilisational Dialogue has triggered a political controversy, with the Congress questioning the Modi government's decision to invite a leader who has previously issued threats against India.

In today’s episode of DNA, Rahul Sinha, Managing Editor of Zee News, conducted a detailed analysis of the political row, examining the diplomatic obligations behind Malik's visit, India's position on Pakistan and the Congress's criticism of the government.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi inaugurated the first SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum in New Delhi on November 20. A photograph from the inaugural event became the centre of a political debate after the Congress shared it on social media. The picture showed Prime Minister Modi seated just three chairs away from Pakistani minister Musadik Malik.

Delhi Chief Minister Rekha Gupta and Malik's wife were seated between the two leaders. The Congress highlighted the photograph by marking Modi and the Pakistani minister in red circles, questioning the government's decision to welcome a Pakistani leader who has repeatedly made controversial remarks against India.

Congress questions Modi government's decision

The Congress accused the Modi government of extending hospitality to a Pakistani minister despite his repeated threats against India. In a social media post, the party alleged that Malik had threatened to cut off India's hands and warned of bloodshed.

It further accused Pakistan of promoting terrorism and being responsible for the deaths of Indians, while the Indian government was allegedly preparing to welcome its minister with biryani and kebabs.

Describing the invitation as a betrayal of the country and its people, the Congress said India should not engage with Pakistan until it completely ends its support for terrorism.

Several Congress leaders also expressed their displeasure over Malik's presence in India, pointing to his earlier statements on the Indus Waters Treaty.

Why was Pakistan invited to the SCO event?

The controversy raises an important question: why did a government that has maintained a tough position towards Pakistan invite one of its ministers to India?

The answer lies in India's responsibilities as a member of the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation. The first SCO Civilisational Dialogue is a multilateral event being hosted in New Delhi from November 20 to 22, 2026. All 10 SCO member countries, including Pakistan, were invited to participate. Observer countries and dialogue partners were also extended invitations.

India had officially invited Pakistan's Culture Minister, Aurangzeb Khan Khichi. However, Islamabad decided to send its Climate Change Minister, Musadik Malik, instead.

The SCO has 10 member countries: India, China, Russia, Pakistan, Iran, Belarus, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan.

As the host of a multilateral event, India is expected to follow the organisation's established protocols and facilitate the participation of its member countries. These arrangements include invitations, visas, security and diplomatic privileges for visiting representatives.

The diplomatic framework allows India to maintain its position on bilateral issues while continuing to fulfil its responsibilities within an international organisation.

No bilateral talks during Musadik Malik's visit

Malik's arrival marks the first visit by a Pakistani minister to India in three years. However, both the Indian Ministry of External Affairs and Pakistan's Foreign Office have clarified that no bilateral meeting is scheduled during his stay.

The Ministry of External Affairs said India is hosting the first SCO Civilisational Dialogue in New Delhi from November 20 to 22, 2026, as a multilateral event under the SCO framework. All member countries, including Pakistan, along with observer states and dialogue partners, have been invited.

The visit comes against the backdrop of heightened tensions following the Pahalgam terror attack and India's subsequent Operation Sindoor. Official bilateral visits and talks between the two countries have remained suspended since then.

No Indian minister has visited Pakistan after Operation Sindoor. However, in September 2026, Additional Secretary in the Ministry of External Affairs Alok Dimri travelled to Islamabad to attend an SCO meeting.

The last visit by a Pakistani foreign minister to India was in May 2023, when Bilawal Bhutto Zardari attended the SCO Foreign Ministers' meeting in Goa. In October 2024, External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar travelled to Islamabad to attend the SCO Council of Heads of Government meeting as the Prime Minister's representative.

Why India cannot afford to boycott Pakistan at international forums

India's participation in the SCO is also important for its wider diplomatic, economic and strategic interests.

A boycott of the organisation's meetings could reduce India's influence over decisions and joint declarations. Its presence is important to prevent proposals that may go against its interests, particularly given the close relationship between China and Pakistan.

The SCO represents around 40 per cent of the world's population and approximately 30 per cent of global GDP. The organisation also provides India with an important platform to strengthen trade and energy cooperation with Russia, Iran and Central Asian countries.

India is keen to maintain its position as a responsible leader of the Global South. Staying engaged with multilateral organisations, even amid bilateral tensions, is an important part of this approach.

Pakistan's upcoming SCO chairmanship for 2026–27 is another factor. Islamabad is scheduled to host the SCO leaders' summit in 2027. A complete breakdown in engagement at the organisational level could create complications for future meetings and India's participation in the summit.

Pakistan could have sent an official instead of a minister to the New Delhi event. However, it chose to send Musadik Malik, signalling the importance it attaches to maintaining engagement within the organisation ahead of its upcoming chairmanship.

Musadik Malik's Indus Waters Treaty remarks

The Pakistani minister's visit has also revived attention on his earlier statements regarding the Indus Waters Treaty.

Malik had made controversial remarks against India following the suspension of the treaty, including threats that drew strong reactions in India. However, the issue did not feature in his public remarks after arriving in New Delhi.

India has repeatedly maintained that blood and water cannot flow together, reiterating its position on the Indus Waters Treaty following Pakistan-sponsored terrorism.

The controversy surrounding Malik's visit has therefore highlighted the distinction between India's bilateral position towards Pakistan and its obligations as a member of an international organisation.

Blind Cricket Asia Cup final sparks another India-Pakistan controversy

Meanwhile, another controversy involving India and Pakistan emerged in Bangladesh during the men's Blind Cricket Asia Cup 2026 final.

The final between India and Pakistan was scheduled to take place in Dhaka. However, continuous rainfall forced the match to be abandoned without a toss or a single ball being bowled.

Following the cancellation, the match referee declared Pakistan the winner on the basis of its superior net run rate. However, the Technical Committee of Blind Cricket had reportedly decided that both teams should be declared joint winners.

The decision triggered further controversy because Syed Sultan Shah, chairman of the Pakistan Blind Cricket Council, is also the president of the World Blind Cricket Council.

India objected to the decision, alleging that the rules had not been followed. Indian players boycotted the trophy presentation ceremony, while the Indian side lodged an official complaint with the World Blind Cricket Council.

The incident has added another dimension to the ongoing debate over India's sporting and diplomatic engagement with Pakistan, with questions being raised over the application of rules and fairness at international platforms.

Stay informed on all the latest news, real-time breaking news updates, and follow all the important headlines in india news and world news on Zee News English.

Add Zee News as a Preferred Source
TAGS:

About the Author

Zee Media Bureau is the editorial news desk of Zee Media Corporation, one of India’s leading news networks.The bureau represents a collective of experienced journalists, editors, and correspondents who work across television, digital, and social platforms to deliver timely, accurate, and wide-ranging news coverage. Zee Media Bureau's coverage spans politics, business, economy, technology, health, entertainment, and global affairs. The bureau follows a collaborative newsroom model, where stories are researched, verified, and published by a team. This ensures speed, editorial consistency, and adherence to journalistic standards, particularly for breaking news and developing stories.
Read More

ZEENEWS TRENDING STORIES