EKI Energy to move SAT as two auditors differ over revenue recognition
The carbon credit company questions SEBI's reliance on one auditor's interpretation of its accounting treatment
The carbon credit company questions SEBI's reliance on one auditor's interpretation of its accounting treatment
The accounting treatment adopted by EKI Energy Services Ltd for its carbon credit projects has come under regulatory scrutiny after two chartered accountancy firms arrived at different conclusions on the same contracts. SEBI accepted the later auditor's assessment, but the Indore-based company believes the earlier auditor's interpretation also merits consideration. It is now preparing to take the matter before the Securities Appellate Tribunal (SAT).
In its October 30 order, the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) observed that EKI had recognised ₹197.04 crore in revenue prematurely during the first three quarters of FY 2022-23. According to the regulator, the distribution and registration of cookstoves under the company's clean cooking projects did not, by themselves, complete the contractual obligations. The verification process and subsequent delivery of carbon credits were still pending.
EKI tells a different story about how the numbers came to be. Its earlier statutory auditor reviewed the quarterly results carrying this revenue and did not object to the treatment, the company says. Its next auditor disagreed and qualified the third quarter results. SEBI’s order backed the second auditor.
The dispute turns on Ind AS 115, the accounting standard that ties revenue to the delivery of what a contract promises. For a cement maker or a carmaker, that moment is easy to spot. A carbon project is a longer road. Cookstoves are installed in village homes, the project is registered, emission cuts are monitored, an independent agency verifies them and only then are credits issued. Where along that road the revenue becomes earned is a judgment call, and two qualified firms made different calls.
The money itself was never in question. EKI says the contract amounts came in from identified buyers, and that it paid income tax and GST on them in the same quarter.
Once the second auditor’s view was on the table, EKI went with it. The company revised its figures before the FY 2022-23 accounts were closed, and the audited annual statements carry the corrected numbers. The changes were disclosed to the stock exchanges.
SEBI’s order takes note of this. According to EKI’s filing with BSE, the regulator treated the revision as a mitigating factor and accepted that management had applied its mind to the accounting question. The order records no quantifiable gain from the alleged defaults, no quantifiable loss to investors and no repeat default.
Other government agencies that looked into EKI did not take penal action. The Ministry of Corporate Affairs examined an inspection report on the company under Section 206(5) of the Companies Act. In a letter dated April 2, 2026, the ministry decided against any penal action under Sections 447 and 448, the law’s fraud provisions. The Income Tax Department’s scrutiny assessment for FY 2021-22 accepted the company’s returned income without a single change.
Which of the two auditors read the contracts correctly is the question EKI wants the tribunal to settle. In a November 2 filing with BSE, the company said it is preparing an appeal “before the Securities Appellate Tribunal under Section 15T of the SEBI Act, 1992.”
Meanwhile, business carries on. The order places no curbs on EKI’s operations, and its carbon projects, credit trading, clean cooking programmes and advisory work for clients at home and abroad continue.
EKI’s case comes down to this. Two professionals disagreed, the company sided with the stricter one and corrected its books within the year. That, it argues, is good faith, not misreporting.
Stay informed on all the latest news, real-time breaking news updates, and follow all the important headlines in india news and world news on Zee News English.